So that’s settled then….?

The result of the British General Election is clear enough, even if its consequences for parliamentary government are not. Mrs May has led her party to the verge of defeat, while Mr Corbyn has shown himself to be civilised, tough and successful. Here in Scotland, Nicola Sturgeon has been shown that most Scots do not want independence,  allowing Ruth Davidson a niche as the representative of ordinary Scots, while Kezia Dugdale has benefitted from the policies of a UK leader she doesn’t rate. The personal and political future of some of the most powerful people in the land has been altered, without violence, by means of public discussion and the vote. This means of asserting the popular will has doubtless many defects, some of which may become obvious as the struggles of a hung parliament are played out, but it remains something to be noted and celebrated.

Probably a largely discredited Tory party will continue to rule with the assistance of the  Democratic Unionists of Northern Ireland, which will mean a continuation of unrestrained capitalism as our favoured economic model, with all its imposed restraints on the welfare of poorer people and public services. Indeed, even if Mr Corbyn were to succeed in cobbling together a ruling coalition, he would almost certainly have to forego some of the boldest polices he has proposed for social justice.

All of which means that those who suffer from unrestricted market forces, the poor, the sick, the people dependent on benefits, the people who need or work for public services, the workers whose skills are exploited by huge multinational companies, will continue to suffer; those nations and peoples damaged by our support of international capitalist trade will continue to be damaged; and those who long for a more just and peaceful society will continue to be disappointed. No sense of appreciation for social democracy should be allowed to obscure the harm that will  continue to be done.

In other words, not much is settled by this election result. Mr Corbyn in a speech yesterday used the words of Shelley, “ye are many, they are few” as encouragement to his supporters. The trouble is that as long as capitalism can satisfy the minimum demands of two thirds of the electorate, Shelley’s arithmetic will not add up to change. In a few weeks the hope of justice will be back in the hands of the saints who battle for it through community groups, charities, and trade unions as well as those who try to provide some small measure of it through their work in public service and social enteprise.

Politicians who want social justice and are not content with the result of this election, must not in their disappointment forget the victims of capitalism nor the saints who work for them. They should be involved in these basic struggles, helping them win their battles and trying to build a more inclusive movement for social justice. There are some signs that the Corbynistas promote this solidarity, while misdirecting it into sectarian political identities. The strength of grass-roots activists is that they are not saddled with existing political identities and can form genuinely popular institutions that will refresh our politics if they are encouraged to do so. The struggle continues.

And what about the Church? The truth is that for years now my church’s General Assembly has promoted social justice, but the response of its members has been partial: on issues of world poverty for example, they have maintained support for Christian Aid, which makes a huge contribution to the neediest people in the world; but in respect of domestic politics have probably not much altered their class bias. My guess is that church people round Scotland will have allied themselves more with their communities of residence than with each other in this election. But just perhaps, their common faith and belonging holds out the possibility of mutual political education, if any activists dare to enable it. The church is not and is not meant to be the kingdom of God; but it is meant, in word and action, to point to it.


  1. Beautiful statement! The saints – how tremendous to use the biblical term to describe those who must continue the fight for social and economic justice! I watched the election returns on BBC World News to 1am my time – 6am London time – when the results were pretty much final. I was amazed by many thing that you Brits can be proud of. What a contrast with US elections. I loved how in each constituency the results were announced with all – or all the main – candidates sharing the stage! A true image of communitarian government that is so much more possible in a parliamentary democracy than in the US. Here it is TV networks that announce the winners, who then speak to their own supporters and congratulate the losers by phone. But that’s a feature of the US in general. Losers and winners generally don’t mix. In most US sports events, the losing team simply disappears and leaves the field to the winners to celebrate. There are no handshakes as you have at the end of football matches. At the Super Bowl, only the losing coach goes over to congratulate the winning coach; his players have already left the field! I kept looking at the map of constituencies as they were being filled in by party colors and I couldn’t help but snickering. All of them approximate circles, with nary a sign of the re-districting and gerrymandering that happens in the US.

    I agree with your assessment of the election and what it means for the poor and other gospel people. But there is at least one good thing that I can point out, again in contrast to the US. You had two terrorist attacks immediately before the election. Yet the anti-Islam UKIP party was completely decimated and May’s hard Brexit strategy facing serious challenge, even if she forms a majority government with the DUP. If two terrorist attacks had happened in the US in the weeks immediately prior to a national election, do you think anti-Islamists would have been hurt?

    No, you can rightly lament much about the results of this election, but I tell you that democracy still stands tall in the UK, and elections do mean something in your country. I admire the fortitude and resilience of the British people even after repeated terrorist attacks. That’s something Trump does not understand, which is why he attacked the mayor of London. But keep fighting for the truth, my friend. Keep preaching the gospel of the saints! You are one of those saints that Christ has poured forth to heal the world’s wounds. I truly love what you wrote here, one of your best commentaries!


  2. We have a great hymn that begins, “Join all the glorious names” and ends “a feeble saint shall win the day/ though death and hell obstruct the way.” It is my favourite, because if I accept the name “saint” as is biblically correct, it has to be preceded with the adjective “feeble.”

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s